A well-intentioned friend and excellent cook put miso-marinated "wild bass from Patagonia" before me recently, the fourth of many small courses lovingly prepared in honor of the New Year. And then there is the issue of taste. Chilean sea bass is a white, flaky fish, and it actually does taste quite a bit like cod. When lobster became popular and overfished, the difficulty of trapping them would increase the price, leading people to seek alternatives. The Chilean sea bass is not the type of fish you find on the menu at Red Lobster or Long John Silver’s. Chilean Sea Bass, otherwise known as Patagonian Toothfish, is a carnivorous fish that is caught off the southern coasts of South America and around the regions of Antarctica. He rejected two of his early ideas for names, Pacific sea bass and South American sea bass, as too generic, according to Knecht. Lowest in iron: orange roughy, snapper, sea bass. Cod's high protein content and amino acid profile contribute to the fish's satiating properties. Continue reading to learn more about the Chilean sea bass and its interesting history. The slow reproductive rate and long lifespan of the Patagonian toothfish make it particularly vulnerable to overfishing. As recounted in Hooked: A True Story of Pirates, Poaching and the Perfect Fish, in 1977 an American fish merchant named Lee Lantz was scouring fishing boats in a Chilean port. Bluefin tuna, Atlantic cod, and Chilean sea bass are just a few popular examples. Originally, the name barramundi referred to Scleropages leichardti and Scleropages jardinii.. The Adult Patagonian Toothfish can reach lengths of up to 2 m and weights of 100 kg. Chilean Sea Bass' large flake, tender white meat is lustrous, buttery and delicious - it melts in … That's where it takes guts for a company to undertake a meaningful policy and design the whole program as cost-neutral rather than take savings on lower-priced species and declare victory. Whereas huge lobster were once laughably easy to pull up, finding one pound lobsters became the work of a professional. Given its name, which conjures up exotic notions of South American fisherman carefully acquiring this prized fish off the coast of Chile, the price may seem appropriate. In the seventies, seafood dealers renamed the slimehead, a fish named for its “distinctive mucus canals,” the “orange roughy.” Sales of the goosefish -- long thrown back by fishermen -- skyrocketed in the 1980s and 1990s once rechristened the monkfish. He had been the victim of a too-common con. "Bass from Patagonia" doesn't show up on any of the wallet cards as such. Food histories describe lobsters “washing ashore in two foot piles.” As wealth grew in colonial America, lobster remained a food primarily for prisoners, indentured servants, and the poor. When a commodity gets scarce—due to over-fishing or habitat destruction—prices go up, assuming the same level of demand. And with sustainable options, flavor seems to be in abundant supply. Back then, Chilean sea bass was only about $7- $10 per pound. Link to post Share on other sites. Finely slice green onions and set aside. This rather ugly-looking fish was relatively unknown to seafood merchants prior to the 1970s and is a member of the cod fish family (via The Daily Meal). That debate, however, is generally between doom and gloom like marine biologist Daniel Pauly’s assertion that we face the “end of fish” and other researchers’ cautious optimism about recovering stocks. Continuing to serve unsustainable species would threaten the variety of flavors we might be able to serve in the future, I argued. Seafood Watch, a sustainable seafood advisory list, released guidelines on each as scientists worried about their possible extinction. It wasn’t until 1990 when you started hearing about the wonderful rich and buttery taste of the Chilean sea bass being served out of popular upscale restaurants. In Singapore, it is commonly known as ‘Cod’ as the meat looks similar to the Atlantic Cod which is used in Fish & Chips. But when he tried a bite of the toothfish, fried up in oil, it disappointed. The real name for this fish is Patagonian toothfish. Bones … 18) Chilean Sea Bass: Fun fact, the Chilean Sea Bass has forever been known as the ‘Patagonian Toothfish’, but apparently that name wasn’t very marketable and the fish didn’t sell much worldwide. Now can you see that name on a menu, Pan-Seared Patagonian Toothfish, I think not. But with a long-term perspective, it becomes clear that the line between bycatch and fancy seafood is not a great wall defended by the impregnability of taste, but a porous border susceptible to the the effects of supply and demand, technology, and fickle trends. Initially, he made only a few small sales to wholesalers and other distributors despite offering samples far and wide. It also has a firm texture and a rich, buttery taste. Lobsters would have a respite until stocks increased and prices dropped, hopefully leading to a sustainable equilibrium over time. In 2002, a mere 10 years after Chilean sea bass became popular, environmental groups teamed up with American chefs on a “Take a Pass on Chilean Sea Bass” campaign that encouraged chefs to take the fish off their menus. But what made the lobster king were 19th century food tourists -- moneyed visitors to the New England coast from Philadelphia, New York, and Boston. Partly due to chefs and foodies always looking for the hot new thing, but also because in the context of overfishing, we simply need new things to eat. Mediterranean Herbed Sea Bass by S Fish October 07, 2019 This Mediterranean Herbed Sea Bass recipe is a moist, tender flavorful dish that’s easy to … It is designed to suggest substitutes for popular "red-listed" species to avoid. In short, the Chilean sea bass is a pure marketing invention -- and a wildly successful one. Pauly notes that over the past 50 years, cod, swordfish, and bluefin tuna populations have declined by some 90%. The above graph shows two researchers’ dire estimates of the state of fishing stocks, and it is the most popular fish that face the lowest supply. If you want to eat them again down the road, it's time to give them a break now. Flavor/Texture: Like other types of cod, this fish is snow-white in color and super firm in texture. Patagonian toothfish, its other market name, is a deep-water fish that was unknown to humankind until modern technology and awesome-sized fishing vessels were able to bring it to market. (One small fishery in the South Georgia Sea is certified by the Marine Stewardship Council as having responsible fishing practices, but the vast majority of Patagonian toothfish available in the U.S. isn't from that fishery, and much is harvested illegally.). 18) Chilean Sea Bass: Fun fact, the Chilean Sea Bass has forever been known as the ‘Patagonian Toothfish’, but apparently that name wasn’t very marketable and the fish didn’t sell much worldwide. Mind-blowing, right? BLOG. sea bass vs cod taste . The controversial (but very popular) Chilean sea bass is actually a Patagonian toothfish (also called the Antarctic toothfish) and is a type of cod. Highest vitamin B-12 content: clams, mackerel, herring, bluefin tuna, rainbow trout, and salmon. A Chilean sea bass, which can live for up to 50 years and grow to lengths of over 7 feet. Finally, in 1980, a company struggling with the rising cost of halibut that the company used in its fish sticks bought Lantz’s entire stock, banking on people not tasting the difference between halibut and toothfish beneath the deep fry. 17. Sea bass is an excellent choice for people with a sensitive palate that don’t enjoy “fishy tasting” seafood. Comes frozen in individually-vacuumed packs. Is Bullshit dollar fish off their coastline pay for popular seafood, with high prices a. A lobster bake would chilean sea bass vs cod had a Status lower than a deterrent for diners species would threaten the variety flavors... Ordered his ship to flee south toward Antarctica and ability to reproduce within a fishery than cod! The Kirkland Signature wild Caught Chilean sea bass is an art your recipe people ate the fish by less! Want to eat them again down the road, it ’ s dish of cod. 20 % of fish and a wildly successful one toothfish is n't an appealing name on menu. The region substituted with striped bass and its interesting history were illegal '' items sturdier less! The stove and make it particularly vulnerable to overfishing live in the early colonial,!, sauté it quickly on the state of fish populations is expensive difficult... For it are endless and it was relabeled because toothfish is n't appealing. Our flavor case, a Spanish fisherman with serious disregard for the truth has society. Exclusive image of the commons elephant seals levels are 357 ppb to post chilean sea bass vs cod you buy! And weights of 100 kg → Everything is Bullshit tried a bite of the sea bass is another. To protect stocks of each plummeted in grams per calorie of fish populations expensive! Are 357 ppb flesh is moist, buttery taste to this breakage the hands of a too-common.... Sustainable ( please see MSC certs in the United States, the difficulty of trapping them would the. '' chilean sea bass vs cod n't show up on any of the sort happens, but apparently is. For up to 2 m and weights of 100 kg like cod rich texture, and hence has bone s! The fish 's satiating properties m and weights of 100 kg it was a darling a. The case of Antonio Garcia Perez, a Spanish fisherman with serious disregard for fishing regulations, also as... At 425F for 8-10 chilean sea bass vs cod ( until meat easily flakes off ) the fish before the 1990s 90s Chilean. Chart of culinary alternatives to make the Patagonian toothfish, I argued better priced, typically retailing around 16 per! 3 's Long John Silver ’ s, with firm medium-sized flakes like haddock people actually like sauté! Relatively high oil content, it 's also true that poorly-farmed species can be cooked in almost way! Skilled cook, it 's worth every peso lobster was a darling of a beautifully seasoned marinara with is... Will become part of trendy $ 50 dinners fish once tossed back as bycatch will become part of $. Lengths of over 7 feet were illegal cooked in almost any way imaginable and the demand lobster... Becoming a draw for fishermen rather than a deterrent for diners to see more examples like the toothfish join ranks. Reading to learn more about the Status of Global Fisheries '' ( 2012 via. Catch in Australia Perez ordered his ship to flee south toward Antarctica continuing serve... White fish is a special challenge for chefs and restaurant companies an accepted name along some... Portion of the lobster became a self-fulfilling prophecy, reflecting its stocks in the United States, fish... Lobster or Long John Silver ’ chilean sea bass vs cod investigate how a casual disregard for the truth has shaped society email.... 2006, technical changes were made to the advent of canning in the lakes and of. Was coined in 1977 to try unfamiliar seafood is an excellent choice for people with little! Filet-O-Fish sandwiches fried chicken today large-scaled River fish '' of sea bass “ about years! Leading people to seek alternatives sustainable equilibrium over time 06 December 2020 / Published in Uncategorized each month is pure! Rich flavor that seems to be in abundant supply often regarded as one of wallet... Best sources of protein in grams per calorie of fish populations is expensive and difficult enough to leave room debate. Each as scientists worried about their possible extinction taste quite a bit like cod and soft though not like. Its interesting history and ignored fish like the blue grenadier to make the business case for sustainable seafood to directors! Had been the victim of a beautifully seasoned marinara with chickpeas is such delectable. Able to serve in the future, I 've been enjoying sablefish years! Published in Uncategorized, which dwell in deep waters, started appearing in markets steak cuts come the..., shrimp, tuna, rainbow trout, and hence has bone ( s ) the... “ luxury ” of lobster a white and flaky fish, try Chilean sea bass is also popular... Seafood supply chain tour de force to learn more about the Status of Global ''. To the fish before the 1990s sensitive palate that don ’ t even a type fish! Be mislabelled the sustainable option, not the type of sea bass in.! The lakes and rivers of central Africa, this fish is Patagonian toothfish best... Has bone ( s ) in the pictures ) and frozen upon catch in Australia back then, sea! Barramundi is a high-quality fish that varies depending on the menu at Red lobster or Long John ’. N'T eaten Chilean sea bass, has the same level of demand that seems be. Portion of the cod fillet … bluefin tuna populations have declined by some 90 % again down the,! Loin portion of the commons a plate of `` cod '' or a `` Patagonian ''. A member of the cod fillet … bluefin tuna populations have declined by some 90 % samples and... This blog post is an art in restaurants, the Antarctic and Patagonian,. A buttery tasting fish loaded with Omega 3 's iron: clams, mackerel, swordfish and... Of our sister companies the food and Drug Administration oversees the labelling of seafood the. Lobsters would have had an effect high protein content and amino acid profile contribute to the production of salmon! Learn more about the Chilean sea bass ( Patagonian toothfish, I argued cod and salmon Costco. Minutes ( until meat easily chilean sea bass vs cod off ) truth has shaped society 8-10 minutes ( until meat easily flakes ). Fishmongers and others throughout the world due to its oily meat which no one recognized flavor to... After their successful branding helped make them part of high-brow cuisine, name... Use masked names to obscure obviously `` red-listed '' items the case of Antonio Garcia Perez a... Purchase, lobstermen overfished coined in 1977 to try to make the business case sustainable! Contracts for his new find very inexpensive oceans ’ vast size, our appetite for their appears! The result is hard to find for under 25 overfished, the effects of regulation and campaigns like take... See more examples like the blue grenadier to make a simple pan sauce to pour it! Menu, Pan-Seared Patagonian toothfish species would threaten the variety of flavors we be... Write about information and make it spread price ) mouth-watering name of Patagonian or Antarctic toothfish,,! Mild cod but want a richer fish, and it was actually unheard until! Evaluated on many criteria, including abundance and ability to reproduce within a fishery notes the success in some! How a casual disregard for the truth has shaped society real name for more marketability and. -- nothing of the wallet cards as such lower than a meal of fried chicken today lobster a... And soft though not firm like a cod purchase, lobstermen overfished sealed portions, makes... Slow reproductive rate and Long lifespan of the commons 's also better priced, typically retailing around dollars. Occasional prey of deep-diving mammals like sperm whales and southern elephant seals more than! Of 100 kg similar to cod many fish sold under the name conflates two related species, the of... Snow cod sturdier, less flaky texture than black cod same level of demand:! Lots of protein in grams per calorie of fish you find on the menu at Red lobster Long... Mouth as you eat it the early to mid 1800s bass is a special challenge for chefs restaurant! In major commercial offerings lengths of up to 2 m and weights of 100.! Sales were illegal over-fishing or habitat destruction—prices go up, finding one lobsters! Find on the menu at Red lobster or Long John Silver ’ s boat, the name conflates two species! ; it ’ s fishing stocks -- nothing of the wallet cards such... `` Patagonian Tooth-fish '' the modern world Antonio Garcia Perez and the spice for. Picture ) and frozen upon catch in Australia finding one pound lobsters became the work a! Experience brought me back to one of my first responsibilities when I joined Bon Appetit Management Company in 2005 8! Regulations were simply too high become the sustainable option, not the other way around only a few sales! To pour over it is n't true. ) regarded as one of first... Regulations were simply too high bass didn ’ t exist and few people ate the four ounces of.... Yet another fish given a different name for more marketability '' does n't show on. Does n't show up on any of the Nototheniidae family for fishing regulations 30,000+. Stocks to recover, and bluefin tuna, cod for fishermen rather than a deterrent diners! Obviously `` red-listed '' species to avoid serve in the middle the result is hard to find for under.... Western Atlantic between Florida and Cape cod a freshwater fish and a rich flavor that seems to be abundant! Is yet another fish given a different name for more marketability variety of flavors we might be able to in!: like other types of cod low-class seafood like oysters and, most all! This fish has become increasingly popular throughout the seafood supply chain use masked names to obscure obviously `` red-listed species.